Azerbaijan, Baku, April 26 / Trend /
The European Court's decision on Azerbaijani journalist Eynulla Fatullayev's case is contrary to the Convention and the case law of the organization, Azerbaijani Supreme Court's Judge Ali Seyfaliyev believes.
In his statement, Seyfaliev noted that Fatullayev was convicted under the Azerbaijani national courts' decision for the specific crimes and currently he serves sentence.
"According to the Article 129 of the Azerbaijani Constitution, the courts take decisions on behalf of the state and the execution of these decisions is mandatory. This means that the convicted can not be released from the legally imposed sentence at the request of any official organizations and international agencies, as well as the international court's decision. A parole of convicted persons is possible only through national courts on the basis of statutory rules," he said.
The website of the European Court on Human Rights published European court's decision on the basis of Fatullayev's complaint April 22.
Based on the decision, provisions of the Convention on Human Rights and the protection of fundamental rights were violated during the criminal proceedings against Fatullayev. European Court demanded the immediate release of Fatullayev.
Seyfaliyev said besides the fact that the decision contradicts the earlier decision, it must be regarded as interference in the sovereign affairs of states.
"Thus, the Court has repeatedly stated in its decisions on the considered cases that does not fulfill the role of the high instance, does not consider the evidence and does not address the issue of guilt. At the same time the European Court has repeatedly stated that cannot change evidence valuation by the national courts (for instance, decisions for "Grayson and Barnham against the UK", "Olsson against. Sweden and others). In my practice, when it detects a violation of the provisions of the Convention, the European Court holds that State for redress. But the demand to release Fatullayev contradicts the case law of the European Court, which has no such authority under the Convention," Seyfaliyev said.
He said the Article 455 of the Azerbaijani Criminal Procedure Code provides introduction of violation of the provisions of the rights and freedoms in the judicial acts. Determination of violations of the Convention on Human Rights on the European Court's decision is of the requirements of Article 455.2 of the Code implying that in the conduct of criminal cases by the Azerbaijani courts, with simplified pre-trial materials for the production or manufacture of special charges. The articles 456 and 457 include rules of court documents on the violation of the rights and freedoms.
"The European Court's decision taken upon Fatullayev's complaint noted a violation of rights under provisions 6 and 10 of the Convention. The Court has found a violation of other rights of the plaintiff under the Convention, including violation of the right of liberty and security, as well as illegal punishment. Therefore, the European Court's demand for the immediate release of Fatullayev is contrary not only to the practice of the court itself, but also the provisions of the Convention ," Seyfaliyev said.
Seyfaliyev said taking this decision, the Court did not sufficiently study the case and did not take into account the requirements under the Azerbaijani legislation.
"So, in terms of legislation providing the production of new cases on violations of human rights and freedoms, in case of violation of the rights of the convicted, the person shall in no case released from the verdict. But, holding of the necessary measures for restoration of rights is in the state's power and it shall do so in accordance with the law. From this perspective, we believe that the Court is not empowered to deny the state's right to choose of the state and local courts about the violation of human rights and give directions. Implementation of such powers by the European Court is regarded as functioning as a court of fourth instance. Any decisions and acts adopted by the European Court according to the requirements and recommendations of the European Convention and national legislation of the European space must coincide with the international and national laws, and this also applies to a decision on the complaint Fatullayev ," he added.
The European Court's decision can be performed in accordance with Azerbaijani legislation after consideration under the relevant procedures.