Azerbaijan, Baku, Sept. 4 / Trend T.Konayayeva /
Conclusion of temporary marriages undermines the basic family values, entails negative consequences for women and for the family in general and contradicts the basic requirements of the Koran, experts say.
"Sharia mainly should focus on the maintenance of a healthy society, and the family, no doubt, is the core of society," Theologian Ramil Vekilov told Trend. "First should be provided building of healthy families to create a healthy society. I believe that temporary marriage undermines the principles of existence of healthy families and can cause some problems. "
Lately, the protests do not stop in connection with the discussions of the Family Protection Bill, which was first presented in 2007, by the Iranian parliament. Aug.30, the parliament session decided to submit Articles 22, 23 and 24 on marriage, remarriage, and Mehr (dowry) to the legal policy and nation-building commission for reconsideration.
The Article 22 allows the registration of temporary marriages, which were practiced in Iran, but not recorded.
Vekilov said most Islamic scholars prohibited namely temporary marriages, because they undermine the foundations of a healthy-strong family.
"There are different views in the Islamic world on this issue," he said. "Jaafari (Shiite) conclude temporary marriages in legal base. Shiite Muslims have their own religiously grounded arguments about temporary marriages, which are not accepted by the Islamic community."
Unlike other legal schools of Islam, temporary marriage (Arabic version zavaj-ul-mut'a - "marriage for pleasure", a Persian version - "Sige") is allowed in Shi'ism and has actively practiced for centuries in places of the Shiites resettlement, including in Iran. This is a contract agreed between a man and woman on marriage for a certain period, ranging from a few hours and days to years.
Such marriages were observed before Islam in the heathenism era (paganism). Islam initially allowed temporary marriage in case of emergency, such as during long military campaigns. By faith of some Muslim communities, after Prophet Muhammad issued a final decision on its banning at all times.
The director of Women's Studies Program and an Assistant Professor of cultural Anthropology at Boston University, author of the "Law of Desire: Temporary Marriage in Iran" book, Shahla Haeri, believes that temporary marriage can hardly serve to maintaining of healthy family and stability of marriage.
"Usually temporary marriage is done secretly and men do not let their wives know about their affairs and so that injects an element of distrust and dishonesty into the marriage and the relationship," Haeri wrote Trend in an e-mail.
Officially, the argument goes, men need to have a woman to keep their when they are away from their wives, she said.
"This way, men are presumably protected against "falling into sin," as the saying goes and women (presumably widowed or divorced women) can get financial support. But then this is not the whole reason for it," Haeri added.
In 2007, Iranian Islamic revolution's leader Imam al-Khomeini's grandson Ayatollah Hussein al-Khomeini noted that "temporary marriage has a place in the Shiite law as a legal institution, because it is aimed to free people from the temptation of adultery, but this form of marriage is very poorly implemented in practice, frequently becoming adultery".
Professor and Director, Center for the Study of Culture, Race, and Ethnicity, Ithaca College, Asma Barlas, does not consider temporary marriages good under any circumstances or for any reasons, since it is mainly intended to satisfy the sexual needs of men and the majority is performed in secret.
"Not all Muslims accept the legitimacy of temporary marriages," Barlas wrote Trend in an e-mail. "If we turn to the Koran, the marriage should not be based on lust and secrecy (5:5) In addition, men preferred to marry only once, so they do not remain indifferent to their wives (4:3)."
Not give way to passion, not enter into an illicit relationship or secret love affairs (Koran 5:5).
If you're afraid that will not be fair to the orphans, then be afraid to also be unfair to your women. You can marry two, three, four at a time, but no more, and you should be sure you will be fair to all. If you're afraid that you are not fair, then marry one only or those who your right hand have mastered (Koran 4:3).
It is difficult to imagine how one can combine a temporary marriage with the teachings of the Koran, Barlas said.
"It is also difficult to see how the family, as a whole, can be healthy or prosper when the husband is on the lookout for another woman whom he can marry on 'the side,' as it were," she said.
Purpose of polygamy in the Koran, is not to enable male sexual access to women and nor is it a way to allow them to have more children, especially sons. Rather, it is meant to ensure justice for female orphans, Barlas said.
"Consequently, even if some wives 'give' their husbands permission for a temporary marriage, such a marriage still remains outside the bounds (hudud) of what the Koran considers good, moral, and best," she noted.
In accordance with the norms of Islamic family right, temporary marriage is the most acceptable form of family relations. The marriage with two, three or four women is more canonical exclusion that is recognized by Islamic family right, but is subject to several conditions. Sharia does not call for polygamy and does not consider it obligatory.
Based on the basic principles of Islamic right and based on historical traditions, conditions have been laid for the new marriage: infertility or inability of his first wife to childbirth, war or the postwar period, when the unmarried women or widows are more than men; physiological characteristics of men, which are expressed in excessive sexual activity (provided that he can provide two or more families), which can lead to adultery.
Nadya Khalife, the Middle East North Africa researcher in the women's rights division at Human Rights Watch, also believes that there is no advantage to temporary marriage.
"Such marriage leaves girls and women quite vulnerable because they are sexual in nature and there's no other connection between the couple," Khalife wrote in an e-mail to Trend.
Khalife said temporary marriages leave women in difficult situations because a woman may get attached to this man who is only seeking sex and becomes emotionally vulnerable, she may feel used, become pregnant.
According to Dr Ziba Mir-Hosseini, Senior Research Associate at the Centre for Middle Eastern and Islamic Law, SOAS, University of London, this deal that was presented by Ahmadinejad's government is actually a deal which has been much protested by Iranian woman, formed a coalition of women coming from conservatives, reformists and seculars.
"They are opposing this this Bill that is coursed for the protection of family, but woman groups are calling destruction of the family because it destroys the basis of the family," Mir-Hosseini told Trend in a telephone conversation from London.
It is a controversial deal and it should be seen in line with other policies of the current government in Iran which has a very narrow interpretation of Islam and also it is authoritarian, absolutely patriarchal and anti-woman, she said.
"If it has an opportunity, it wants to undo all achievements that Iranian women had in the past seventy years," Mir-Hosseini said.
"I don't think that these two laws are going to be passed," she said.
"But if they are going to be passed, it will be a real damage to the family and Iranian women and it's totally out of line with contemporary values of Iranian society," Mir-Hosseini said.
However, supporting the Family Protection Bill, the rector of the Al-Zahra College for Girls in Iran Mahbuba Mubashiri said that the articles in the Bill are aimed at protecting women who faced problems.
She said that the essence of this law has been wrongly presented to the public.
"Some people argue that the bill allows a man to get married to several women, Mubashiri told Trend by telephone. The noise was raised around article 27 of the bill, which gives men the opportunity to marry four women, but it is wrong to interpret this article in this form."
She added that according to this article, men are conditioned for the second marriage: the consent of his first wife and marriage under the law.
"A man must appeal to court in order to marry a second wife, said Mubashiri. And he must have grounded reasons to go to court."
In 2006, the judiciary proposed the Family Protection Bill that was basically aimed to fill the vacuum that was created in law in Iran after the revolution. In fact the law was very good. There was no mention of polygamy or temporary marriage there.
Before the revolution there was the Family Protection Bill which was put in act in 1967 by the previous regime which established a new court and took the unilateral right of divorce away from a man and put it in the hand of a court. So, if a man and woman wanted to get divorced before 1967 there was no need to come to the court if a husband wanted to divorce because a husband has a unilateral right to divorce. But after 1967 it was the court who decided and a man needed to provide a ground and a reason for divorce. The law gave men and women more or less equal access to divorce.
After the revolution this court was dismantled but not repealed. In the place of this court a new court came that was headed by religious judges.
Then in 1997, a new law passed and created a family court. But at the same time, the Family Protection Bill from the previous regime was not repealed while some of its articles were repealed. Therefore, there were several laws, there was 1931 Marriage Law, 1967 Family Protection Law, and the regulations of these laws sometimes were contradictory.
In 2008, Ahmadinejad's government presented for consideration the articles 22 and 23, which resulted in widespread protests and contributed to the formation of women's coalition. In September 2008, about 100 women with well-known Iranian human rights activist Shirin Ebadi and poetess Simin Behbehani discussed with parliamentarians and lobbyists the elimination of these two articles. Then the MPs rejected the bill.
However, after the political crisis in 2009, the government used the opportunity to resubmit the bill with those two articles, but made some changes to them. For example, the current version of article 23 provides 10 grounds on which a man could ask for permission for a second marriage. Consent of the first wife is one of them.